Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 - ss. 16 and 34 -
Applicability of the Act - Arbitration petition u/s. 34 -
Maintainability of - Parties-appellants entering into two
Product Sharing Contracts (PSCs) with the Government of
India, providing for exploration and production of petroleum
- Disputes between parties regarding payments of royalties,
cess, service tax and GAG audit report- Notice of arbitration
- Constitution of arbitral tribunal - Under Article 33. 12 of
PSCs, the venue of arbitration would be London -
Amendment in the PSC, by agreement of the parties, Final
Partial Consent Award by arbitral tribunal that juridical seat
for arbitration would be London, England - 'Final Partial Award
that appellants' claims are arbitrable - Petition u/s. 34 by
respondent challenging Final Partial Award - Allowed by High
Court holding that the arbitration petition was maintainable -
On appeal, held: Petition u/s. 34 is riot maintainable -
Applicability of Arbitration Act, 1996 to the arbitration
agreement has been excluded - It cannot be said that even
though the arbitration agreement would be governed by the
laws of England and that juridical seat of arbitration would be
in London, Part I of the Arbitration Act would stiff be applicable
as the laws governing the substantive contract are Indian
Laws - Upon a meaningful reading of the said Articles of the
PSC, that the proper law of the contract is Indian Law; proper
law of the arbitration agreement is the law of England -
Applicability of Arbitration Act, 1996 has been ruled out by a conscious decision and agreement of the parties - In the
event, final award is made against the respondent, the enforceability of the same in India, can be resisted on the
ground of Public Policy- Remedy against the award will have
to be sought in England, where the juridical seat is located -
International Commercial Arbitration.
Doctrines/Principles - Principle of separability - Held:
Permits the parties to agree that law of one coμntry would
govern to the substantive contract and laws of another country
would apply to the arbitration agreement.