Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 - 01: 7 r 11 - Rejection of
plaint - On facts, election petition by respondent challenging the
election of the appellant - Application u!Or. 7 r 11 by appellant for
rejection of the petition by way of counter affidavit - Non consideration of the same since there was no formal application
and court proceeded with the trial - Subsequently, formal application
for rejection of the petition by appellant - Non-disposal of the same
and posted along with the main petition as also denial of opportunity
to the appellant to file written statement - On appeal, held:
Application u/01: 7, r. 11 can be filed at any stage - Court has to
dispose of the same before proceeding with the trial court - There
is no point in proceeding with the trial of the case - Petition is only
to be rejected at the threshold - Appellant entitled to file the
application for rejection before filing his written statement and in
case, the application is rejected, appellant is entitled to file his written
statement thereafter - Procedure adopted by the court not warranted
under law - Thus, the impugned order is set aside - Since the
application does not come within the purview of any of the situations
u/01: 7 r 11 (a) to (j), application is rejected - Appellant given an
opportunity to file written statement in the Election Petition within
the stipulated period