Service Law: Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules 1972: r. 43
– Maternity leave – Entitlement to – Female government servant- nursing officer applied for maternity leave on the birth of her first
biological child when she had already taken the benefit of child
care leave in respect of the two children born to her spouse from his
first marriage – Rejected by the tribunal as also the High Court –
On appeal, held: Independent of the grant of maternity leave, a
woman is also entitled to the grant of child care leave for taking
care of her two eldest surviving children whether for rearing or for
looking after any of their needs, such as education, sickness and
the like – Both maternity leave and child care leave constitute distinct
entitlements – The fact that the nursing officer’s spouse had two
biological children from his first marriage would not impinge upon
her entitlement to avail maternity leave for her sole biological child
– Grant of child care leave to her cannot be used to disentitle her to
maternity leave u/r. 43 – Unless a purposive interpretation were to
be adopted, the object and intent of the grant of maternity leave
would simply be defeated – Grant of maternity leave under the Rules
of 1972 is intended to facilitate the continuance of women in the
workplace – Child birth has to be construed in the context of
employment as a natural incident of life and hence, the provisions
for maternity leave must be construed in that perspective –
Furthermore, the guardians and caretakers-mother and father, of
children may change with remarriage, adoption, or fostering – Such
atypical manifestations of the family unit are equally deserving not
only of protection under law but also of the benefits available under
social welfare legislation – On facts, the structure of the employee’s
family changed when she took on a parental role with respect to
her spouse’s biological children from his previous marriage – When
courts are confronted with such situations, they would do well to attempt to give effect to the purpose of the law in question rather
than to prevent its application – Thus, the nursing officer was entitled
to the grant of maternity leave – Judgment of the High Court and
the tribunal is set aside.